About Me

I am an Emory University (Atlanta, Georgia) student doing Sociology with a Journalism co-major. My home is in Dubai, United Arab Emirates and I am an Indian by nationality. This summer, I went on a trip to South Africa for a study abroad internship with Bush Radio (89.5FM). As a part of our program requirement we had to document our experience and reflect on it. This is my story...
Showing posts with label IV. Readings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IV. Readings. Show all posts

Journal Entry 17- Assesment of the novel "Disgrace" by J.M. Coetzee






(clip: trailer of the movie adaptation of Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee)

From the first few pages to the end of the story, a reader will go from feeling revolted about the character David Lurie to pitying him and then eventually feeling happy for his choice. His journey from womanizer to accepting grandfather is so well constructed and intriguing that one cannot help but want to know more about him. David’s relationship with his daughter Lucy is also one of the most interesting angles in the book and the scrutiny with which the book explores it is quite fascinating. But what is most unique about the novel is the background in which the story takes place; South Africa after apartheid.

While the scandal in the book seems equivalent to that in any other American novel, it is the turn that the story takes to the rural Grahamstown in the Eastern Cape that makes it different. The timing of the novel is extremely important. There is no mention of what the political situation is like in the beginning, but one can suppose that it takes place in the present because the element of oppression is never included in the book. Prejudice is however an element that is not ignored and is touched upon often. Immediately, what some reviewers call the white dilemma comes into the picture when black and Colored South Africans enter the story. It's what drove both David as a white male to shame. At first though Coetzee does not blatantly state the race of the characters and it is usually after some clues that we figure it out. Like Petrus, it was only from the description of his role at Lucy’s farm, David’s suspicions of Petrus’ absence during the attack and more details provided at the party that we find out that Petrus is black. Even the rapists did not seem black at first because again there was no particular indication.

Clearly Lucy’s unwillingness to tell the police about her rape or to move from the farm or to confront Petrus about his brother-in-law Pollux’s involvement indicates her belief that she needs to be sensitive because it is a race issue. Even David’s hands are tied as he cannot accuse Petrus “like the old days” and yet he has a nagging feeling that somehow Petrus had some connection and in a way was responsible. Though his suspicions do come true, the fact that the thought jumps into his head angers Lucy and could be seen as prejudiced. Hence the white dilemma in South Africa is highlighted.

David’s sex-capades and the constant reference to Byron are symbolic too. I think in many ways he sees himself as Byron, who was known for his love affairs. While Byron was a poetic genius, he did commit many mistakes. For David, his affairs serve as the premise for his personal downfall, which is furthered by his inability to protect his daughter and often overlook his intellectual pride.

It is known that Coetzee is an animal rights activist and so the inclusion of animals around the plot may have been to raise awareness. The animal “disposal” center that Bev Shaw runs, subtly points fingers at those who abandon animals. But David’s character develops along with the death of each dog he handles. At the very end of the book he says that the virtue of being a kind grandfather will come as his other virtue of lust goes as well. Those parts of him die as disposes of the bodies of the dead dogs.

The title Disgrace applies to almost every character in the book; Lucy’s disgrace of rape and having to live with the result of it for her entire life, David’s disgrace of scandal and of the attack, Petrus’s disgrace of his brother-in-law, Bev's disgrace of euthanasia. It’s their social context and confounding history that is the cause of their pain and disgrace.

Journal Entry 18- Relating my experiences and perceptions of South Africa with "Disgrace"




(clip: trailer of movie adaptation of Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee)

I think one of the strongest themes in the book that stuck with me is the white dilemma. Before reading the book my perception of race relations between white and black South Africans was based on what I read about the country’s history. Black and Coloured people were oppressed under the system of apartheid and the notion of separate development. Years after the historic struggle that eventually overthrew the National Party and their ideology, prosperity has still not reached all levels of society. Wherever we went around Cape Town, we would see townships like Khayelitsha that are striving to survive and then we would visit white rich areas like Stellenbosch, a completely opposite situation there. At that point of time I felt that justice had not been served and that white South Africans had not completely integrated themselves with the majority population.

After reading that book however, I became a little sympathetic towards white South Africans and their conflicting mindset. This situation could be influenced by certain factors; there may still be some resentment towards whites who live on land previously owned by black families for centuries. Those families that do try to integrate may experience hostility that stems from the frustration of poor economic situations. Also, the criminal courts and police during apartheid were hardly beacons of justice, especially for blacks. Hundreds upon thousands of them were thrown in jail indefinitely and for wrong reasons. Many were tortured to death, an issue the Truth and Reconciliation committee tried to address. But now in post-apartheid South Africa shown in Disgrace, white people like Lucy are torn between getting justice for themselves and not using their white privileges as the generations before did. It is indeed a dilemma. I think from this book I somehow understood this better but now the situation in South Africa just seems even more complicated to me.

It also made me think in general about race in literature. When reading novels of lighter genre like romance, sometimes the race of a character becomes unclear and we usually paint a picture in our mind depending on our own definitions. In more serious genres that have political backdrops, we figure out the race based on the roles played by the character. As I mentioned in the earlier entry, race in Disgrace is confusing. There are no initial indicators of the racial backgrounds of the characters in the books. Even though the setting of the book is in a place with complex history, race first an unimportant element in the first few chapters eventually becomes a subtle factor.

Also, during my internship at Bush Radio I had once talked with a guest on the show about the difference between Cape Town and the rest of the country. He said that sometimes people viewed Cape Town as elitist and a completely different and developed scenario from parts like the Eastern Cape. Everything in Cape Town he said is seen as better. David’s journey from his comfort zone in Cape Town to the rural Grahamstown would mean, from the guest’s description, as such an enormous step. I never had the chance to go to the Eastern Cape but from the details provided in the book, I think I would feel completely lost just like David.

Journal Entry 19- Reflection on "Long Walk to Freedom" by Nelson Mandela







While the first spark of wanting to become a leader and being involved came from Nelson Mandela’s early observations of a village meeting, it seems that his time in Robben Island were the more formative years of his leadership skills. Before that his role was that of a prominent Africa National Congress member and a representative. He says it himself that at Robben Island his diplomatic/ lawyers skills and articulate language often were the reasons behind inmates choosing him as a medium for their concerns. Mandela was hardly a rabble-rouser and rarely lost his temper. A calm demeanor and a polite attitude he seemed to believe were key to getting things done, but that did not mean that strikes and boycotts were out of the questions. Even though he was not a complete believer of Mahatma Gandhi’s non-violence strategy, he was not a supporter of violence that harmed people and preferred sabotage. In the later years of his imprisonment Mandela encountered young radicals who believed his manner was too soft and moderate. But during most incidents, he was chosen as the spokesperson, thus harnessing his negotiation skills. Globally, Mandela today is one of the most loved figures and it seems his personality is such that one can take an instant liking to him. At one point he states that he is able to get along and befriend people comfortably. This might have helped during any round of negotiations he has had to deal with. While in Pollsmoor Prison, Mandela decided to talk with government officials without consulting the main ANC committee and in secret. It seems that this quality of taking risks and making decisions that might jeopardize his reputation and position is what he deems important. To “move out ahead of the flock” and go off another tangent for the betterment of the group can either lead to being celebrated or condemned. But Mandela does agree that keeping the masses informed and engaged of occurrences is vital to gain their trust. Towards the end of the novel he talks about twin obligations a person has; to their family and to their country. But in South Africa during apartheid Mandela said it was almost impossible for a man of his background to ignore the needs of his nation. That ability to sacrifice one’s family and personal life no matter how much criticism a person may come under seems to be what he values. Mandela seems aware of the consequences and has made his peace with it. It is all a part of his thinking as a group and not as individuals to fight oppression.


Mandela described himself as being born free but politicized his entire life. He said there was no particular time when he suddenly decided to become a freedom fighter and combat racism. It was a more gradual process. However one can trace his realization to when he came to live in Alexandra Township and work at the law firm in Johannesburg that he really began to experience the oppressive conditions that black South Africans faced. But his attitude is not that of anti-white or anti-Indian or anti-Colored but inclusive of all races. It was while he was studying at Witwatersrand that his mind opened up to different political beliefs and ideas, something he says would not have happened back in Transkei. Mandela’s attitude was not that to only uplift the black community and blame one particular race for the situation but the system and the government behind it. Even during his speech when he was released he reiterated constantly that white South Africans were as much a part of the country as everyone else and would not be driven to the sea. It was a matter of miscommunication and assumptions that were encouraged by the government. With the understanding of the situation Mandela did his best to educate people and spread awareness even when he was in Robben Island by talking about the aims of the ANC to the warders. In prison he became very conscious about interacting with prisoners of different backgrounds. Most of his speeches were directed to no particular race and chastised the National Party government and system for purporting racial conflict. Even during the negotiation process he tried to reason with other parties that felt threatened. I think his associations and acquaintances with ANC members of diverse backgrounds like Chief Albert Luthuli, Bram Fischer and Ahmed Kathrada and even outside the party like Robert Sobukwe were proof his all-encompassing vision for South Africa. In many ways the ANC’s eventual ascent to power with its somewhat diverse member base may have been a factor behind why the country is today quite rich in ethnicities and communities.